Man of the people is attracting voters fed up with Merkels reign | Hans Kundnani

Man of the people is attracting voters fed up with Merkels reign | Hans Kundnani

click photo for more information
Man of the people is attracting voters fed up with Merkels reign | Hans Kundnani
Neither charismatic nor visionary, he has proved unexpectedly popular since announcing he would run to be chancellor Until a couple of weeks ago, it seemed that one of the few things you could be certain about in a time of huge uncertainty elsewhere in the west was that Angela Merkel would become German chancellor for […]

Neither charismatic nor visionary, he has proved unexpectedly popular since announcing he would run to be chancellor

Until a couple of weeks ago, it seemed that one of the few things you could be certain about in a time of huge uncertainty elsewhere in the west was that Angela Merkel would become German chancellor for a fourth term following this Septembers election. The February issue of the magazine Cicero showed Merkel emerging from a ballot box with the headline: Whats the point of voting anymore? The only real question was what kind of coalition she would lead: yet another grand coalition of Christian Democrats and Social Democrats (the third in four electoral periods), or possibly the first ever black-green coalition?

It was not as if Germany was immune from the rise of populism that is creating such extraordinary upheaval elsewhere in Europe and the United States though some in German initially believed it was. The Eurosceptic and anti-immigration party, Alternative fr Deutschland (Alternative for Germany, AfD), scored a series of stunning successes in regional elections in 2016 and polls suggested it would win somewhere between 10% and 15% of the vote in the election in September. But the German electoral system and the dynamics between the six parties expected to win seats in the Bundestag actually meant that the better the AfD did, the more likely it was that there would be another grand coalition led by Merkel.

Then Sigmar Gabriel, the Social Democratic Party (SPD) leader who had been expected to be its candidate, dropped out and European Parliament president Martin Schulz took his place and suddenly everything looked different. The SPD had been polling in the mid-twenties for years and was so resigned to its fate that in 2015 a senior Social Democrat even wondered publicly whether they needed a candidate at all for chancellor, since Merkel was doing such an excellent job. But immediately after Schulz announced his candidacy in late January, the SPD shot up to around 30% in the polls neck-and-neck with the Christian Democrats. Suddenly, there seemed to be a realistic chance of a Social Democrat winning a general election in Germany for the first time since 2002.

The excitement around the candidacy of Schulz is something of a puzzle he is hardly a charismatic or visionary figure. Some think of him, though, as populist of the centre because of the way he presents himself as a man of the people. He does have a compelling biography: he dropped out of high school, hoped to become a professional football player and struggled with alcoholism. But the most plausible explanation for his sudden popularity is that it reflects pent-up demand for a real alternative to Merkel, who many Germans are fed up with after more than a decade in power. Since the refugee crisis began in the summer of 2015, many voters angry with her approach to it turned to the AfD. But the polls suggest some of those voters might now vote for Schulz, with the AfD slumping below 10%.

Schulzs big advantage is that, unlike Gabriel, who had been economics minister since 2013 and took over as foreign minister a month ago, he is not implicated in the right-wing economic policies of the two grand coalitions under Merkel, in which the SPD has been the junior partner. Since the financial crisis of 2008, the Social Democrats have aligned themselves with Merkel and in particular backed her hawkishness on deficits. Most of Schulzs career, meanwhile, has been spent in Brussels rather than Berlin. He can therefore credibly attack Merkel and offer an alternative especially on economic and social policy.

The SPDs problems go all the way back to the red-green government of Gerhard Schrder between 1998 and 2005. In particular, the Agenda 2010 reforms that he introduced in 2003 which cut social security and health care benefits, reduced state pensions and made it easier to fire employees alienated many working-class voters, especially in the east of Germany. In 2005, Oskar Lafontaine, who had been Schrders finance minister for a few months before resigning, formed a new left-wing party, Die Linke, which won 9% of the vote at that years election. Nevertheless, the SPD stood by Agenda 2010, which they claimed was decisive in the turnaround in the German economy in the mid-2000s. (In reality, the outsourcing of production to central and eastern Europe, and wage restraint, were more important in making German manufacturing competitive again.)

Since then, it has become almost structurally impossible for the Social Democrats to lead a government unless it can overcome its differences with Die Linke which includes former East German Communists and form an R2G, or red-red-green, coalition of Social Democrats, Die Linke and the Greens. After another ignominious defeat in the election of 2013, Gabriel took over as party leader and sought a rapprochement with Die Linke. But then came the Ukraine crisis, and the gap between Die Linke and the SPD on foreign policy especially in relation to Russia widened rather than narrowed. The SPD was back to square one.

But in his first big campaign speech in Bielefeld last week, Schulz attacked Agenda 2010, saying that the SPD had made mistakes that it was now necessary to correct. He criticised the increase in income inequality and the growth of insecure and badly paid jobs in Germany in the past decade, which he blamed on a neoliberal mainstream that had declared workers rights and social welfare to be obstacles to growth. This left-wing rhetoric came as a surprise. Schulz was not generally seen as one of the more left-wing figures in the party, says Sebastian Dullien, a Berlin-based economist.

Some hope that, were Schulz to be elected, a shift to the left on economic policy might also offer a way to bridge differences with France on eurozone policy especially if independent candidate Emmanuel Macron is also elected as French president in May.

Since the euro crisis began in 2010 the Social Democrats have increasingly supported Merkels unyielding approach and sometimes for example, in the summer of 2015 when her finance minister, Wolfgang Schuble, threatened to kick Greece out of the euro seemed to want to be even tougher on the left-wing Syriza government. Now they are suddenly talking about the suffering of the Greek people.

In Bielefeld, Schulz called for more investment in education, infrastructure and digital technology. But there are limits to how far even Schulz will go. He is not considering a rethink of the Schuldenbremse, or debt break, that the Social Democrat finance minister Peer Steinbrck introduced in Germany in 2009 and has since been imposed on the entire eurozone to limit deficit spending. That is not up for debate, Schulz ally Ralf Stegner told Reuters. Nevertheless, the Christian Democrats are likely to tell voters that he wants to mutualise eurozone debt and create the transfer union that they fear in other words, an EU in which the fiscally irresponsible endlessly subsidise the fiscally responsible.

However, while an R2G government led by Schulz could be good for the European Union, it could be disastrous for Nato, whose future now hangs in the balance since the election of Donald Trump as president of the United States. The Trump administration has made it clear that it wants European allies to rapidly increase defence spending to reach the target of 2% of GDP to which they are committed. If they dont, the US may moderate its commitment to Nato, as Defence Secretary James Mattis ominously put it earlier this month.

Merkel has agreed to increase Nato spending albeit slowly and with caveats. But Social Democrats do not see the need to increase spending at all and prefer the idea of deepening defence co-operation with France.

It is not yet clear whether Schulzs current popularity is sustainable or merely a bubble that will burst over the next few months especially as the Christian Democrats step up their attacks on him (Schuble has already compared him to Trump). There also remain difficult questions about whether, even if they secure a majority in the Bundestag after the election, the Social Democrats, the Linke and the Greens can reach agreement on policy especially on Russia. In some ways, says Jrg Lau, foreign editor of the Hamburg-based weekly newspaper Die Zeit, it will be harder than ever to do so now that Trump is in the White House: If the SPD softens the tough line towards Moscow, it will be suspected of strengthening an authoritarian coalition that is plotting against Europe and western values.

Hans Kundnani is a senior transatlantic fellow at the German Marshall Fund and the author of The Paradox of German Power

Read more: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/feb/26/germany-schulz-spd-elections-merkel

Sen. Murkowski on health care bill: ‘I don’t have enough information’

click photo for more information
Sen. Murkowski on health care bill: ‘I don’t have enough information’
Washington (CNN)Republican Sen. Lisa Murkowski said Monday that she doesn’t “have enough information” to vote for on the Senate GOP’s health care bill. Murkowski’s comments come just hours after the Congressional Budget Office released a report on the Senate bill’s impact, prompting multiple Republicans to express doubts about the legislation or reiterate that they would […]

Hack that plants ISIS message hits another state government website

click photo for more information
Hack that plants ISIS message hits another state government website
(CNN)A government website in the state of Washington is the latest victim of a hacking attack that plants what appears to be pro-ISIS propaganda. A screen shot provided by the spokesman shows the same Arabic logo and claim that the hack was carried out by “Team System DZ,” the same language that appeared on hacked […]

McConnell’s test: Can he do more than obstruct?

click photo for more information
McConnell’s test: Can he do more than obstruct?
(CNN)Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell is facing a major test this week. Since revealing the details of the Republican health care plan, McConnell has watched as a number of important senators in his own party announced their concerns or opposition. Some, such as Wisconsin Sen. Ron Johnson, have urged him to postpone the vote based […]

Holland & Barrett sold for 1.8bn to Russian billionaire – BBC News

click photo for more information
Holland & Barrett sold for 1.8bn to Russian billionaire – BBC News
Holland & Barrett has opened more than 300 stores in the seven years since the private equity takeover, the Financial Times reported. Rush on rosemary sales for exam season H&B accused of squeezing suppliers The purchase is the first by L1 Retail, which was set up in late 2016. It aims to invest $3bn in […]

BMA chief: NHS is ‘running on fumes’ – BBC News

click photo for more information
BMA chief: NHS is ‘running on fumes’ – BBC News
NHS staff shortages: Why so persistent? You’ll wait longer for ops, says NHS boss He said: “We have a government trying to keep the health service running on nothing but fumes. A health service at breaking point. “Run by ministers who wilfully ignore the pleas of the profession and the impact on patients. “It doesn’t […]

Church leaders in power-sharing plea to NI politicians – BBC News

click photo for more information
Church leaders in power-sharing plea to NI politicians – BBC News
The appeal is made in a letter signed by Church of Ireland Primate Richard Clarke, the Catholic Primate of All-Ireland Eamon Martin, Laurence Graham, President of the Methodist Church in Ireland, Bishop John McDowell, President of the Irish Council of Churches and Noble McNeely, Moderator of the Presbyterian Church in Ireland. The letter was sent […]

Mother of boy with rare genetic disorder tweets hospital bill

click photo for more information
Mother of boy with rare genetic disorder tweets hospital bill
(CNN)As lawmakers push to get a health care bill through the Senate, one New Jersey mom is speaking out. On Friday, she tweeted her son’s latest hospital bill and it went viral. “It seems fitting that, with the #TrumpCare debate raging, I got this bill in the mail today from Ethan’s most recent open heart […]

Transgender firefighter marches as NYC Pride Parade grand marshal

click photo for more information
Transgender firefighter marches as NYC Pride Parade grand marshal
(CNN)When Brooke Guinan joined the New York City Fire Department in 2008 she publicly presented herself as a man. She had no idea that on Sunday she’d be one of the NYC Pride Parade’s grand marshals while identifying as a transgender woman. Before joining the department, Guinan was unsure what her professional life would look […]

Mom shares the crushing cost of her son’s medical care before the Senate votes on healthcare bill

click photo for more information
Mom shares the crushing cost of her son’s medical care before the Senate votes on healthcare bill
Before the Senate votes on its bill to repeal the Affordable Care Act, many people are sharing stories of how the bill would affect them. One story struck a chord with thousands of Twitter users this weekend. The mom of 3-year-old Ethan Vikash shared a photo of a medical bill for her son’s open heart […]

ObamaCare Battle: Pro-Trump group previewing attack ads on GOP Senator Heller

click photo for more information
ObamaCare Battle: Pro-Trump group previewing attack ads on GOP Senator Heller
The pro-Trump super PAC that vowed an ad campaign against Nevada Republican Sen. Dean Heller within hours of him on Friday opposing the GOPs ObamaCare overhaul bill previewed its attack Saturday on social media. Why did @SenDeanHeller lie to voters about #RepealAndReplace? Hes now with @NancyPelosi. NOT GOOD! #HellerVotesYes, tweeted America First Policies, run by […]

The teenagers growing up with cancer – BBC News

click photo for more information
The teenagers growing up with cancer – BBC News
For Natasha, and for all patients undergoing chemotherapy, going bald changes the way they see themselves and how other people view them. She says: “It is so confusing because I miss the old self. “Before I thought I’m never going to walk out bald, I’ll always have my wigs on every time I walk out […]

Man Cited For Driving Motorcycle Through Crowd Of Trumpcare Protestors

click photo for more information
Man Cited For Driving Motorcycle Through Crowd Of Trumpcare Protestors
Around 20 protestors, including seniors and people with disabilities, were staging a die-in by lying on the street outside of the San Francisco Federal Building on Wednesday afternoon, CBS San Francisco reported. The man rode his motorcycle down the wrong way on Seventh Street, through the crowd, then turned and drove through the crowd again, […]

Nebraska Democrat fired for saying he was ‘glad’ Rep. Scalise was shot

click photo for more information
Nebraska Democrat fired for saying he was ‘glad’ Rep. Scalise was shot
Washington (CNN)A member of the Nebraska Democratic Party was fired Thursday morning after an audio recording of him surfaced on YouTube saying he was “glad” House Majority Whip Steve Scalise was shot at a congressional baseball game practice and wished the Louisiana Republican was dead. “This motherf***er, like, his whole job is like to get […]

Trump Reaches Out To Lawmakers On Healthcare As Another Says ‘No’

click photo for more information
Trump Reaches Out To Lawmakers On Healthcare As Another Says ‘No’
President Donald Trump made calls to fellow Republicans in the U.S. Senate on Friday to mobilize support for their partys healthcare overhaul while acknowledging the legislation is on a very, very narrow path to passage. White House officials said on Friday that Trump has been in touch with Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and made […]

Grand Jury’s ‘Myth’ Report On A California Jail Snitch Scandal Draws Criticism

click photo for more information
Grand Jury’s ‘Myth’ Report On A California Jail Snitch Scandal Draws Criticism
At the center of the scandal are allegations that sheriffs deputies have for decades planted informants next to targeted inmates in the countys jails and have directed them to fish for incriminating evidence to help secure convictions. While its legal for law enforcement authorities to use informants to help bolster cases, in many Orange County […]
load more posts